2026 - Maya Adkins
2025 - Ella Rahe
2024 - Alexandra Knotts
Top 11 Finalist at Miss Indiana
Preliminary Evening Gown Award
2023 - Shaylee Barnes
Four Points Scholarship Recipient
Non-finalist Talent Award
2022 - Megan Riehle
2020/2021 - Kaitlyn Bestul
(Assumed title after Hannah Bullion)
2019 - Olivia (Dillion) Lundin
Joy of Life Scholarship Recipient
Community Service Scholarship Award
2018 - Meadow Ryann
2017 - Lindsey Franxman
2016 - Michelle Ferro
2015 - Taylor (Knox) Hollenbeck
Top 10
2014 - Lauren Butler
2013 - Taylor (Knox) Hollenbeck
Top 10
2012 - Rachael (Bazzell) Stainko
2011 - Courtney Jurick
2010 - Sable Amstutz
2009 - Emily Hart
Top 10
2008 - Ashley Casterline
4th RU to Miss Indiana
Preliminary Swinsuit Award
Academic Award
2007 - Kaleena Dale
2nd RU to Miss Indiana
Preliminary Interview Award (tie)
2006 - Erin Cleever
1979 - Sall Harter
(Title was Miss Fort Wayne Three Rivers Festival)
1976 - Cindy Whelchel
1975 - Karla Johnston
1974 - Cindy Legler
2nd RU to Miss Indiana
Preliminary Talent Award
Went on to win the title of Miss Indiana 1975 (Miss MidCentral)
Placed top 10 at Miss America
2026 - Hensli Harkless
2025 - Grace Schoegler
2024 - Kinglsey Southard
2023 - Chloe Bollinger
2022 - Amarra Nester
2020/2021 - Katelyn Joseph
2019 - Ella Doddridge
Four Points Scholarship Recipient
2018 - Mara Fivecoat
2017 - Ava Hampton
2016 - Kennedy Barry
2015 - Hannah (Bullion) McCann
2014 - Maddie (Bryan) Fort
2013 - Megan Smaltz
2012 - Daisy Dallas
2011 - Taylor (Knox) Hollenbeck